[Date Prev][Date Next][Thread Prev][Thread Next][Date Index][Thread Index]
Analysis of protium water samples by Saurer
- To: Alexei Vorobyov <vorobyov@pnpi.spb.ru>, Evgeny Maev <maev@pnpi.spb.ru>, Peter Kammel <kammel@npl.uiuc.edu>, Steve Clayton <smclayto@uiuc.edu>, Brendan Kiburg <kiburg@npl.uiuc.edu>, Fred Gray <fegray@berkeley.edu>, Berhard Lauss <lauss@socrates.Berkeley.EDU>, Tom Banks <tbanks@socrates.Berkeley.EDU>, Tim Gorringe <gorringe@pa.uky.edu>, Francoise Mulhauser <Francoise.Mulhauser@psi.ch>, Malte Hildebrandt <malte.hildebrandt@psi.ch>, David Hertzog <hertzog@uiuc.edu>, Alexandre Vasilyev <vassilie@mail.pnpi.spb.ru>, Marat Vznuzdaev <marat@mail.pnpi.spb.ru>, Peter Kravtsov <pkravt@gmail.com>
- Subject: Analysis of protium water samples by Saurer
- From: Claude Petitjean <claude.petitjean@psi.ch>
- Date: Mon, 23 Jan 2006 18:10:49 +0100
- Organization: PSI
- User-agent: Mozilla/5.0 (Windows; U; WinNT4.0; en-US; rv:1.7.3) Gecko/20040910
Dear friends,
last November (2005), Georgii brought us a protium
water sample from a new Gatchina production.
I gave it to Matthias Saurer (Laboratory of Atmo-
spheric Chemistry at PSI) to be analyzed by his
new mass spectrograph, together with former water
samples "Isotec" (from Tim) and "Ontario Aug-02"
(from Canada, first batch).
The resulting ratios (c_D/c_H) are:
"Isotec" -0.40 ppm (former ana +3.0 ppm)
"OntarioAUG-2002" -1.94 ppm (former ana +1.7 ppm)
"Gatchina NOV-2005" -3.14 ppm
Obviously, the results suffer once again from the long
extrapolation of the standard (144.5 ppm) to near 0 ppm.
According to Saurer, the relative differences are however
more reliable.
Therefore, one may conclude, that the new Gatchina water
sample - in view of previous "absolute" ETH results -
seems to be around
0.5+-0.5 ppm (or say < 1 ppm),
which would be very suitable for a new, better protium
gas production!
So I have the following questions to Alexei, Sasha and
Georgii:
Does it make sense, that this new water sample has by
an order of magnitude better deuterium-depletion than
all earlier Gatchina samples??
In case of good reasons: is it possible to get this
water to PSI for protium gas production? When would
this be possible?
Please consider these questions!
Thanks and best regards
Claude